Strict constructionism and loose constructionism in. Also referred to as strict interpretation or original intent, because a person who follows the doctrine of strict construction of the constitution tries to ascertain the intent of the framers at the time the document was written by considering what the language they used meant at that time. Strict constructionists believe that interpreting new rights into the constitution is a dangerous exercise because there is nothing to guide the development of new rights other than a judges individual conscience. Strict constructionists argue against any broad interpretation of the language of the constitution.
Loose discuss with your student colleagues whetheror. As president trump and some of his supporters push for a more rapid return to. Madison was the father assertive textbook version or chief. Strict construction legal definition of strict construction. Loose construction hamilton represented the federalists the federalists supported a strong national government jefferson represented the democraticrepublicans the democraticrepublicans wanted more state power, less national. Thomas jefferson had always feared the costs of loose construction of the powers. When it came to the national bank, he believed in a strict interpretation, as well. Strict constructionism, the judicial philosophy of trumps next. The federalists promulgated a loose interpretation of the constitution, which meant that they believed that the government could do anything by the implied powers of the constitution or that congress had the right to interpret the constitution based on. The first 5 presidents thomas jefferson slideshare.
Loose construction is based on implied powers of article i clause 18 of the constitution. The book also surveys the conflict over constitutional interpretationoriginalism v. Methods of constitutional interpretation strict vs. Strict constructionism definition, examples, cases, processes. Facile invocation of the strict constructionist label tells us very little about how judges will decide particular cases. Its sort of meaningless because sometimes text is unclear. The strict construction of criminal statutes complements the rule of lenity, which holds that ambiguity in a criminal statute should be resolved in favor of the defendant. Loose constructionist definition of loose constructionist. Thus, states rights and a strict constructionist view of federal. Ap government chapter 16 vocabulary flashcards quizlet. I think there is a good argument for this, which i wish would be made more explicit in court opinions on these issues. Loose construction interpretation hamilton represented the federalists the federalists supported a strong national government jefferson represented the democraticrepublicans the democraticrepublicans wanted more state power, less national government power.
On the contrary, he believed in a loose interpretation of the louisiana purchase. Constitution, to apply the text of the law, exactly as written, in making judgements and rulings. One labeled as strict constructionists, the jeffersonian republicans, and the other labeled as broad constructionists, the federalists. Strict construction versus loose construction ap us history. Also, many scholarshave described thomas jefferson as a strict constructionist, basedon the excerpts from the jefferson memorial, would you agree andstate your reasoning. The result will not be an true or constructionist reading of the constitution. It is frequently used even more loosely to describe any conservative judge or legal analyst. By roger roots if you tune into any national political debate these days, you are likely to be subjected to a tiresome dialogue regarding the types of judges that should be nominated and approved to sit on the federal bench. What is the difference between loose constructionism and strict constructionism when it comes to interpreting the u. Loose constructionism should only be referred to in the latters article, if at all, considering how the most content this article ever had was its unsourced definition as the antonym of strict constructionism.
Dec 12, 2007 however, if one really is a strict constructionist of the first amendment, they would still say the fee is not unconstitutional because the text states that the amendment applies to congress only, not public universities. Strict constructionism is a concept relating to legal interpretation that the quizworksheet combination will help you to explore. Since peterson published his book, confusion concerning the mind of. Through the development and drafting of the constitution, two political parties were born. Strict constructionism vs broad constructionism essay 726. Supporters of strict construction believe that the constitution must be interpreted by. Jefferson and the louisiana purchase bill of rights institute. Acceptance and implementation of such loose constructionism would give the. Nov 04, 2012 broad constructionism vs strict constructionism essay. Strict constructionist believes in a literal interpretation of the constitution while a loose constructionist believes that the constitution should be interpreted in light of changing conditions. Nov 07, 2016 originalism emphasizes the original intent of the framers.
James madisons the founding father we quote on the constitution. He believed people should follow exactly what was stated and allowed in the document. In other words, under strict constructionist principles, judges would not be allowed to consider the intent. Strict constructionist definition is one who favors giving a narrow conservative construction of a given document or instrument. Mar 17, 2010 if you reinterpret the constitution, you will reinterpret it from your own perspective. As jefferson scholar john chester miller observed in his landmark book on jeffersons attitudes. Justice antonin scalia, appointed by ronald reagan to the supreme court in 1984, embodies the modern strict constructionist.
This theory contrasts with a loose construction of laws, which allows broader discretion by judges to determine intent in legal language. Thomas jefferson believed in a strict construction of the constitution. It has to change with society, like a living organism, or it will become. Originalism vs strict constructionist 11 justice blair. The tests currently used to see if people are actively infected with the virus are sophisticated molecular tests that can spot its genetic material in specimens swabbed from inside peoples noses and throats. Americans have disagreed about this since the beginning. In the united states, strict constructionism refers to a particular legal philosophy of judicial interpretation that limits or restricts judicial interpretation. For a document that has been the supreme law of the land in the u. Hey all, doing some work on the supreme court and i need some help. Sep 16, 2016 what is the difference between loose constructionism and strict constructionism when it comes to interpreting the u. Jefferson, as a strict constructionist, was chary of a slippery slope. Loose constructionist definition is an advocate of loose construction as of a statute or constitution. Kagans answer flew in the face of the strictconstructionist philosophy espoused by some sitting justices, including conservatives antonin scalia and clarence thomas. A strict constructionist attempts to interpret the law based on the words of the law itself, while a loose constructionist applies a more liberal reading to the text.
Apr 08, 2015 the push to reopen economies is intensifying the need for more, and faster, testing for coronavirus. Whats the difference between originalism and strict. Strict construction is the opposite of liberal construction, which permits a term to be reasonably and fairly evaluated so as to implement the object and purpose of the document. A strict constructionist is someone who maintains the fantasy that he understands precisely what the founding fathers men frequently in great disagreement with one another actually meant collectively in the constitution and the bill of rights.
Strict constructionist means you just look at the text, not any other source. Its a matter of interpretation october 2004, for example, i argued that. Loose construction was for more power of the national government. Questions originalists ask themselves when interpreting the constitution are. Liberal judges are quite adept, not surprisingly, at construing liberally. Would strict constructionism have freed dred scott.
Antonin scalia, a major proponent of textualism, said that no one ought to be a strict constructionist, although to be a strict constructionist was preferred to being a nontextualist. Leaven volume 7 issue 4restoration themes article 4 111999 strict constructionism and loose constructionism in restoration history james b. Dred scott, which restricted congresss power to regulate slavery in the territories and assured chief justice roger b. Thomas jefferson overrules his own inner tenther minnpost.
Suggested by adrev for a 3rd party jim davies ticking timebomb official music video song heart of courage28585. The historical case for strict construction, a structural. Strict constructionisim, or original intent, is a theory limiting interpretation of legal and constitutional language to the literal meaning of this language at the time of passage. The debate between strict and loose construction of the united states constitution has been a feature of the republics history since the very beginning.
Its a simple thing, and not that important but im looking at judicial philosophies and ive got the basis. Strict constructionist definition of strict constructionist. Strict constructionist is the dumb version of originalism. A dfl push to move minnesota to entirely votebymail is complicating. Wade was actually a model of strict constructionism. Federalists push for a stronger central government at the expense of the states. Another thing virtually no one in the legal profession uses the terms loose constructionism or broad. Strict constructionism vs broad constructionism essay 715 words. In contrast, federalists supported loose construction of the constitution. The myth of thomas jeffersons inscrutability history news network.
A yale law professor explains what the phrases strict constructionist and. The loose interpretation states that the federal government can do what is good for the country even if the constitution doesnt explicitly allow it, but the strict interpretation states that the federal government can only do what the constitution says it can do. Oct 26, 2004 facile invocation of the strict constructionist label tells us very little about how judges will decide particular cases. Activists and strict constructionists 2012 book archive. Oct 23, 2015 the term strict constructionism refers to a philosophy of law that would restrict judicial interpretation of the law, as well as of the u.
Loose constructionism vs strict constructionism casual. Originalism means you interpret the text according to the understanding of the text and its meaning at the time of the constitution was written. Loose construction is it is the basis for the forming of political parties under president adams. Yet, while taney construed strictly congresss power, he simultaneously construed broadly constitutional. The question the strict constructionist always asks, of course, is what justification the loose constructionist can give for finding all these new rights in the constitution that arent mentioned explicitly there.
755 1185 140 208 853 1200 720 1431 673 1008 519 633 62 506 991 1253 694 119 657 570 725 1243 825 1392 889 773 246 246 975 127 917 964 812 710 1321 963 875 79