Gilpins theory of hegemonic war was designed to highlight the differences between an approach in international political economy makes to our understanding of the and in international relations. Raewyn connells concept of hegemonic masculinity connell serves as an analytical instrument to identify those attitudes and practices among men that perpetuate gender inequality, involving both mens domination over women and the power of. I then examine the establishment of the post war economic system in the light of these three theories. Robert gilpin, war and change in international politics. Thucydides theory of hegemonic war and contemporary varia tions of t h a t t h e o r y. From hegemonic masculinity to the hegemony of men article pdf available in feminist theory 51. Section 4 applies our theory to the cases of wwii in europe and the pacific. Summary of explanatory perspectives on the iraq invasion theory causalexplanatory focus realism unipolarity, maintain hegemony and avoid post911 decline by demonstrating u. The aim of this paper is to establish a political framework to mitigate the crisis propensity of power transitions in the international system. For a recent reappraisal of the theory of hegemonic order, see g. Hegemonic stability theory meaning hegemonic stability theory definition hegemonic stability theory explanation. A football star is a model of hegemonic masculinity.
The stability of the international system requires a single dominant state to articulate and enforce the rules of interaction among the most important members of the system. Hegemony is dominance and subordination in the field of relations structured by power hall, 1985. Apr 10, 2019 in todays society it takes a lot to grasp the change in how masculinity is supposed to be. Why the rise of china will not lead to global hegemony. According to robert keohane, the theory of hegemonic stability defines hegemony as preponderance of material resources. This conventional approach to hegemony has been challenged from two sides in ir. It maintains that, although it is difficult to define accurately chinas future hegemonic role and general systemic behaviour, a third hegemonic way or dutch.
In the introduction to his history of the great war between the spartans and the athenians, thucydides wrote that he was addressing those inquirers who desire. The stability of the international system requires a single dominant state to articulate and enforce the rules of interaction among the most important members of the system to be a hegemon, a state must have three attributes. Peace is the result of a state where vital interests of dominant states are not threatened. Robert gilpin, the theory of hegemonic war, journal of. The concept of hegemonic masculinity has influenced gender studies across many academic fields but has also attracted serious criticism. The theory of hegemonic stability does not explain the failure of the interwar and the success of the post1945 international economic orders.
Mar 06, 2017 hegemonic stability theory meaning hegemonic stability theory definition hegemonic stability theory explanation. In the branch of realist analysis known as hegemonic stability theory, the presence of a hegemon say, britain in the 19th century and the united states after 1945 generates patterns of stability within the international system. Because the subject is of obvious relevance to the role of the united states in the world, the debate over hegemonic stability theory is consequential for academics and policymakers alike. If the state of disequilibrium is not resolved peacefully, then a hegemonic war is likely to occur. Can the united states be held partly responsible for wwi given its inaction in the early years of the war. Second, the cold war era provides an excellent period to test hegemonic stability theory. Hegemonic masculinity is defined as a practice that legitimizes mens dominant position in society and justifies the subordination of the common male population and. Hegemonic war in this article, robert gilpin discusses the general dynamics of international relations, which thucydides had discovered.
The theory of hegemonic stability is important in understanding the stability and instability in the international political economy. Cultural hegemony has philosophically influenced eurocommunism, the social sciences, and the activist politics of socially liberal and progressive politicians. Benefits of hegemonic stability theory benefits of. Understanding hegemony in international relations theories. When the handsome australian rules football player, warwick the tightest shorts in sports capper, combined football with modelling, does this. Apr 28, 2016 hegemonic war in this article, robert gilpin discusses the general dynamics of international relations, which thucydides had discovered.
In ancient greece 8th century bc 6th century ad, hegemony denoted the politicomilitary dominance of a citystate over other citystates. Aug 15, 2018 hegemonic stability theory, according to keohane, holds that hegemonic structures of power, dominated by a single country, are most conducive to the development of strong international regimes whose rules are relatively precise and well obeyed 1980, p. Connells gender order theory, which recognizes multiple masculinities that vary across time, culture and the individual. The theory of hegemonic stability ths is a significant theory in understanding the roles played by the hegemonic power and the relations with the economic development and political stability in the international structure. Hegemonic masculinity, the persiangulf war, and the new world order. The basic premise of the theory of hegemony is one with which few would disagree. According to gilpin, the theory of hegemonic war founds its origins in thucydides analysis of the peloponnesian war, where, for the first time, the. I follow this with a broad overview of the major theories on hegemony and its role in international relations. While the theory itself may be straightforward, it has complex ramifications for the nature of order in the international system. The structure of the system or distribution of power among the states in the system can be stable or unstable. Hegemonic threats and greatpower balancing in europe, 14951999 3 of the european experience. Analysis of connels theory of hegemonic masculinity.
According to gilpin, a hegemonic war is characterized by three features. Hegemonic stability theory been the focus of substantial scholarly attention in recent years. Section 3 formalizes the theory through a gametheoretic model. Raewyn connells concept of hegemonic masculinity connell 1987 serves as an analytical instrument to identify those attitudes and practices among men that perpetuate gender inequality, involving both mens domination over women and the power of some men over other often minority groups of men. We conclude by offering general predictions on the likelihood of war. The authors trace the origin of the concept in a convergence of ideas in the early 1980s and map the ways it was applied when research on men and masculinities expanded. Vietnam war theories of the university of washington. The limits of hegemonic stability theory international. Classical marxist theory, of course, stresses economic position as the strongest predictor of social differences. In gender studies, hegemonic masculinity is part of r. Conversely, the absence of a hegemon is associated with disorder and undesirable outcomes. Theories of general war world politics cambridge core. Domestic influences upon international monetary cooperation in major states were a crucial determining factor in the global economic stability or lack thereof in the interwar and postwwii periods.
For our purposes here, the theories of world economic cycles are classified as hegemonic theories with weak linkage to the causation of war. Hegemonic stability theory has been advanced as an explanation of successful cooperation in the international system. Pdf powertransitiontheory, liberal hegemony and the. Do hegemonic, or rising hegemonic, powers have a certain responsibility in the international system. Theory of hegemonic war the great turning points in world history have been provided by these hegemonic struggles among political rivals. Section 4 applies our theory to the cases of wwii in europe and the paci c. There are serious problems with hegemonic realist theory, however, as well as gilpins own version of it. We conclude by o ering general predictions on the likelihood of hegemonic wars and extracting policy implications for u.
It is at once political, economic, and ideological. This coincides with the assumptions of hegemonic stability theory hst, which presupposes the cyclical transition of world leadership. Long cycle theory a rather clear linkage with war, however, is shown by modelski and thompson 1989. But when we examine these bearers of hegemonic masculinity, they seem scarcely up to the task, with more than just feet of clay. Thus, the fall of an existing hegemon or the state of no hegemon diminishes the stability of the. Institutions, strategic restraint, and the rebuilding of order after major war princeton, n. Hst is an attempt to 1 explain the historical specificity of the postwar liberal international economic order through a focus on the benign consequences of an uneven distribution of material power in the international system. Thucydides theory of hegemonic war the essential idea embodied in thucydides theory of hegemonic war is that fundamental changes in the international system are the basic determinants of such wars.
One approach that focuses on this phenomenon is the power transition theory originally established. Us dominance or hegemony was the linchpin of the successful world capitalist economy after 1945. The theory of hegemonic war in the introduction to his history of the great war between the spartans and the. The starting point of hegemonic stability theory is the presence of a single dominant state. With the end of cold war, the united states, the frontier of theoretical studies, began to search for a new vision in order to form a new conceptual basis based on the realism to bolster its hegemonic dominance. Instability caused by changes in economy and technology that takes away power from the dominant state. Hegemonic stability theory posits that an assertive hegemon can act as a stabilizing force in the international system. In todays society it takes a lot to grasp the change in how masculinity is supposed to be.
According to this theory hegemonic stability indicates that the relationship in our international systems is likely to remain more stable when hegemon or a single nation dominates the world power. The basis of this hegemonic cooperation is the leadership of the hegemonic state. The theory of hegemonic war the origin and prevention of major. Thucydides theory of hegemonic war causes of war and peace wars are the result of. Causes of war and peace wars are the result of changes to power balance, or unstable balance of power. On the other hand, when one state is firmly in control, they institute a stable economic system which tends to keep the peace. May 28, 2010 hegemonic stability theory is one of the most influential yet controversial ideas to emerge from the field of international relations. Theories of conflict and the iraq war daniel lieberfeld. Hegemony and the global political economy oxford research. War occurs when a rising state challenges the current hegemon, and seeks to overtake the priviliged postion. Its central thesis is that us fear about its declining hegemony and chinas rapid rise as a challenger of us hegemony is driving a us.
To be able to truly understand the sort of expectations that men are held to by society there must be a detailed look into what r. Connell refers to as hegemonic masculinity connell, it justifies mens position in society as head of society and puts women second, saying women are. Hst indicates that the international system is more likely to remain stable when a single nationstate is the dominant world power, or hegemon. According to the theory of hegemonic stability, the role played by a hegemonic power is very importance in creating stability in international politics and economy. To c a r r y out this t a s k, it is n e c e s s a r y t o make thucydides ideas more systematic, expose his basic assumptions, and u n d e r s t a n d his a n a l y t i c a l method.
Farrar distinguishes hegemonic war from probing war and adjusting war he defines hegemonic war as a war that involves a high level of violence and seriously threatens or in fact alters the system fundamentally, usually as a result of one powers attempt to dominate the system p. The hegemon has a selfinterest in the preservation of the system and is, therefore, prepared to underwrite the. Gramsci developed the concept of cultural hegemony in an effort to explain why the workerled revolution that marx predicted in the previous century had not come to pass. Hegemonic stability theory hst is a theory of international relations, rooted in research from the fields of political science, economics, and history. The hegemonic theory of war rests on the interaction between the challenger and the hegemon. The purpose of this paper is to offer an explanation of the underlying cause of the uschina trade war. The first section provides a brief survey of the theory of hegemonic stability and outlines two main competing theories of postwar international economic cooperation, embedded liberalism and alliance leadership.
In a nutshell, long cycle theory describes the connection between war cycles, economic. Central to marxs theory of capitalism was the belief that the destruction of this economic system was built into the system itself since capitalism is premised on the exploitation of the working class by the ruling class. Although an argument about the role of a hegemon in the creation of public goods can be applied to a wide variety of issues in international politics, it has been made most often and most notably in the case of international monetary relations and international trade. Apr 18, 2019 this article analyses chinas strategic intentions and how these may ultimately project its violent or peaceful hegemonic rise. The analytic discourse of cultural hegemony is important to research and synthesis in anthropology, political science, sociology, and cultural studies. Domestic inadequacies and a loss of international prestige has left a growing number of scholars, analysts, and other experts worried about the imminent decline of the united states of america u. Firstly, by neoliberalism, as a critique of hegemonic stability theory hst. The theory of hegemonic war and international change that is examined below refers to those wars that arise from the specific structure of an international system and in turn transform that structure. First, the presence of a dominant actor will lead to the provision of a stable international regime of free trade more broadly, hegemons provide leadership for the emergence of international regimes in various issueareas. Hegemonic stability theory is a theory that attempts to explain changes in the degree to which the international political economy is open or restricted on the basis of the power relations between the major states in the world system. Pdf from hegemonic masculinity to the hegemony of men. Hst or hegemonic stability theory is a theory that deals with international relations. To be a hegemon, a state must have three attributes.
Hegemonic war draws many states in world war, affects the nature and governance of the system, and may use unlimited means. At the time of the vietnam war, which would you consider, between the united states and soviet union, the challenger and which would you consider the hegemon. Three preconditions for the outbreak of a hegemonic war. An economic theory of hegemonic war semantic scholar. Assumptions of the theory underlying thucydides view. Robert gilpin, the theory of hegemonic war, the journal of interdisciplinary history 18, no.
981 1092 772 650 1389 283 369 255 480 203 873 1512 46 1548 1410 843 1523 1242 1161 516 199 789 473 182 855 1049 742 1249 1251 1483 690 1052 732 48 267 1484 1368 1471 1420 1480 587 607 98